Tudor Investassure Pty Ltd

From 1 January 2016, our newsletter will no longer appear in this section. We now send via email  - feel free to subscribe using the panel to the right - or you can connect with us via our social media channels.

Facebook

LinkedIn

Twitter
   

Newsletter Articles

What is the Disposition Effect?

Posted by Naomi Rosenthal on Thursday, May 22, 2014 Under: Investments

The disposition effect

All investors are prone to behaviours and emotions that can lead to poor investment decisions. One of the most common of these is the tendency to sell investments that have risen in value, and hold on to investments that have fallen in value. In 1985 two academics, Shefrin and Statmen, studied this behaviour and coined it the ‘disposition effect’.

The disposition effect quickly destroys value in two ways:

1.       An investor misses out on the returns of a rising asset.
2.       They continue to hold investments that are falling in value.

Of course if an investor sells all the winners and keeps the losers, they eventually end up with a portfolio of losers!

It’s nearly impossible to avoid losses altogether, but it is possible to minimise them. Cutting losses may seem an obvious thing to do, but it’s less common than you might think.

The disposition effect – a case study

It’s January 2012 and David starts the new year by investing $10,000 in casino operator ABC Casino and $10,000 in mining company XYZ Mining.

Six months on, and ABC Casino has performed well, rising by 31%. David is very happy with this return and can’t see the stock rising much further. He sells the stock, earning a $3,100 profit. He is very pleased with his stock-picking ability.

Meanwhile, David’s holding in XYZ Mining has fallen in value by 25% over the six months. He can’t believe his bad luck, but comforts himself that this is only a ‘paper loss’ – because he hasn’t sold the stock yet, he hasn’t realised the loss. David hangs on to the stock because he can’t afford to realise the loss and thinks that one day it will return to what he paid for it.

Fast forward to the end of the 2013, and David still holds XYZ Mining. Because the stock was performing badly, he lost interest and neglected his investment.

Unfortunately, the XYZ Mining share price continued to fall and David’s investment is now worth just $5,035. Even taking into account the profit he made from the sale of ABC Casino, David is faced with a net loss of $1,865. To make matters worse, ABC Casino rose a further 262% after David sold his shares. David is kicking himself for missing out on this return.


In a different scenario, if David had instead sold his XYZ Mining shares and kept his ABC Casino shares, they would now be worth $48,841. Even taking into account the loss he would have realised when selling XYZ Mining, this is a net profit of more than $31,000 on his original $10,000 investment.

This is an illustrative example of what can happen if you sell a winning stock too early and hold on to a losing stock too long. Of course the same principle applies to all investments, whether individual shares or a portfolio of investments.

Exhibit 1: ABC Casino vs XYZ Mining: cut your losses and let your winners run

Source: Bloomberg.

What went wrong

David fell into a few common traps when managing his investment:

Trying to pick the top

Many investors sell their shares when they think they have reached the maximum price and the only way is down. In this example, David thought that the ABC Casino share price couldn’t rise much more after it rose 31% in six months – a stellar return. However, the future value of a stock is completely unrelated to its purchase price.

Self-attribution bias

Congratulating yourself on your stock-picking ability when stocks go up, and blaming ‘bad luck’ when stocks go down is called ‘self-attribution bias’. Many of us are guilty of it. Self-attribution bias leads to over-confidence in investment abilities and deters investors from seeking professional advice.

Regret

When an investment goes bad, many investors comfort themselves and avoid admitting a mistake by viewing it as only a ‘paper loss’. However a loss on paper is just as important as a realised loss. Investors are often willing to realise gains but unwilling to realise losses. This is the underlying cause of the disposition effect.

Neglect

When stock markets are rising, many investors enjoy watching the value of their investment grow and take a keen interest. When investments go down, the opposite is true. It’s important to always monitor and manage your investments whatever the market conditions.

Opportunity cost

Opportunity cost is the price paid for following one choice at the expense of another. In this case study, David has passed up the opportunity of holding a stock rising in value by continuing to hold XYZ Mining.

Breaking even

After an investment falls in value, many investors plan to hold onto it until it returns to its purchase price, meaning they will break even and erase their mistake. Unfortunately, this may never happen. In the case study above, XYZ Mining will have to rise 100% to return to what David paid for it two years earlier. Many stocks never regain their previous highs.

Avoiding the pitfalls

Many investors sabotage their own investment success without even realising. One of the key ways to avoid this is to recognise and understand behaviours and emotions that can lead to poor investment decisions.

Long-term investing in a professionally-managed fund is a good way to avoid the common pitfalls. Experienced fund managers typically apply more discipline to their investment process and so are less inclined to make emotional decisions than investors who hold shares directly.

To discuss your investment portfolio and seek professional advice and management, contact us on 02 9455 0655 today.

 

 

This document has been prepared by Colonial First State Investments Limited ABN 98 002 348 352, AFS Licence 232468 (Colonial First State) based on its understanding of current regulatory requirements and laws as at 1 April 2014. While all care has been taken in the preparation of this document (using sources believed to be reliable and accurate), to the maximum extent permitted by law, no person including Colonial First State or any member of the Commonwealth Bank group of companies, accepts responsibility for any loss suffered by any person arising from reliance on this information.

 

 

In : Investments 


Tags: "investing behaviour" "disposition effect" investing behaviour investments 

Connect with us.

Free Newsletter! Sign up here.

*indicates required

Click here to go to our newsletter archive.

Responsibility for the content and opinions expressed herein rests solely with the author and opinions expressed do not necessarily represent the views and opinions of Professional Wealth Services Pty Ltd.
The information on this website is general in nature and may not be relevant to your individual circumstances. You should refrain from doing anything in reliance on this information without first obtaining suitable professional advice. You should obtain and consider a Product Disclosure Statement (PDS) before making any decision to acquire a product.
This information is for Australian residents only.
Whilst care has been exercised, the taxation information contained is provided as a guide only and may not be relied upon. If in doubt, you should seek independent tax advice from a qualified tax adviser.

Privacy Policy - click here.

Tudor Investassure Pty Ltd | ABN 74 881 211 664 | Phone: 02 9455 0655 | Email: info@tudorinvest.com.au

Post: PO Box 1142, North Sydney NSW 2059 | Office: Ground Floor, 100 Walker Street, North Sydney NSW 2060

Corporate Authorised Representative of
Professional Wealth Services Pty Ltd Australian Financial Services Licence No. 312047 ATF Professional Wealth Services Unit Trust | ABN 58 174 609 776
Office: Ground Floor, 100 Walker Street, North Sydney NSW 2060 | www.pws.net.au